8/30/2008

The simplified technique for an estimation of mechanical characteristics of frozen soils

It is recommended at foundations design and corresponding geocryological survey to use the following simplified models for definition of mechanical characteristics of frozen soils, which are described particularly in the book of Dr A. Gerasimov «Foundations in Permafrost»,
https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version
  1. The proved regional tables of the mechanical characteristics.
  2. Theoretical estimate of mechanical characteristics of frozen soils as composite materials at full or partial absence of test data for similar soils and (or) their components - the book sections 4.3.4, 4.4.2 - 4.4.4, 6.1, 6.2, 7.2 – 7.4; the websites:
    Test-free determination of mechanical properties of ice-rich soils –
    http://permafrost-foundations.blogspot.com/2008/08/blog-post_09.html
    Test-free determination of mechanical properties of saline frozen soils –
    http://permafrost-foundations.blogspot.com/2008/08/blog-post.html
    Thermal stresses and strains in frozen soils (in Russian)–
    http://permafrost-foundations.blogspot.com/2008/08/blog-post_15.html
  3. Time analogies of a stress-strain state of soils with use of universal analytical dependences for creep strains, strength and temperature in characteristic ranges of stresses (the book sections 4.1.1, 4.1.2, 4.2, 4.3.5, 4.4.6, 6.2).
  4. Analytical analogies of soil strains and failure in time (the book sections 4.1.1 - 4.1.3, 4.3.3).
  5. The complex stress-strain theory of soils (the book sections 4.1.1 - 4.1.3, 4.4.5, 7.2.2).
  6. Express-methods for experimental determination of mechanical properties of frozen soils - the book sections 4.4.3, 5.2.1, 5.2.4, 5.3, 7.3.2, 7.4.1, 7.4.2, 8.5, 10, 11; the website:
    http://permafrost-foundations-e.blogspot.com/2008/08/express-method-for-determination-of.html
  7. The known laboratorial methods of determination of tangential forces of frost heave with updating the received values by the soil type and the design temperature (the book sections 7.4.1, 7.4.2, 9.2, 9.3).
  8. The modern laboratorial methods of determination of normal forces of frost heave, and deformations of frost-susceptible and thawing soils - the book section 1; the publications # 7, 20 in the appropriate file (in the attachments) on the website (0.1 Mb)
    https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version

    The useful websites:

8/22/2008

The Site on Foundations on Frost

Foundations designing at presence of frozen soils is a specific problem for regions as permafrost as seasonal frozen ground. The following site of D.Sc. A. Gerasimov is devoted to description of various aspects of the investigations, geocryological survey and designing: https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version

For cold regions Dr. A.S. Gerasimov develops:
  • standards and recommendations for foundation analysis and design;
  • economical methods of geocryological survey;
  • algorithms for mechanical and thermo-physical analysis of foundations;
  • advanced technological know-how for freezing, frozen and thawing soils, foundation design, which provides an economical effect and reliability of foundations;
  • express-methods for testing reference and prototype piles, ground samples, models and punches on freezing and frozen soils;
  • provisions for ecological protection of areas from technological and climatic impacts with proposals to foundations design;
  • specific projects of construction.

It is possible to familiarize oneself on the site with the new book with new ideas of D.Sc. A. Gerasimov “Foundations in Permafrost”.

In the first part of the book ‘Fundamental of Frozen Ground Rheology’ regularities of ice and frozen ground mechanics under constant and variable exposures are settled from analysis of theoretical and experimental investigations. Means of experimental and theoretical determination of rheological characteristics of ground are analysed, which can be used in the foundation engineering on permafrost.

In the second part of the book ‘Settlement and Bearing Capacity of Foundations’ regularities of mechanical behavior of permafrost foundations for buildings are settled from analysis of theoretical and experimental investigations. Methods of experimental and theoretical determination of fundament rheological characteristics, which provide necessary probability of its safe behavior, are analysed. Design methods of estimation of fundament settlement and bearing capacity and also its reliability, taking into account for ground rheological properties, are considered.

Development of design methods of foundations analysis (permafrost as well as thawing and frost-susceptible ones) is provided in the third part ‘Engineering’ planned to issue.

In addition to the book, the useful publications of the author and research projects on the specified subjects are offered for the site visitors (see the attachments).

Besides, discussions on the frost engineering problems is fulfilled through the author e-mail, using FAQ and other publications.

Blog in Russian: http://permafrost-foundations.blogspot.com/


Test-Free Determination of Mechanical Properties of Ice-Rich Soils

The method is described in the book of D.Sc. A. Gerasimov “Foundations in Permafrost” (the sections 4, 6.1, 8.5.2, 11.1, 11.2, 14): https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version


Profit

  1. An analytic method for test-free determination of mechanical characteristics of ice-rich soils as composite materials.
  2. An improved way of computing the design values of the mechanical characteristics of soils by the method of the smallest squares.
  3. Use of the design values in both the linear and nonlinear methods of settlement analysis for columnar and pile foundations.

The Objective of the Research

The objective of the research is to develop theoretically and substantiate experimentally the analytic methods for determination of mechanical properties of ice-rich soils with layered and other cryogenic structures (creep-strength, the point of fluidity, the limit of linear creep, the viscosity coefficient, long-term strength and non-linearity parameters of deformability) by the similar properties of the components (frozen non-ice-rich soil and ice) or by the similar properties of ice-rich soils with a different ice content, determined through experiments or tables.

Approaches

The main working hypotheses approved experimentally:

  • estimation of ice-rich soil properties accordingly to the composite approach is curried out taking into consideration: the cryostructure and iciness at the expense of ice inclusions; physical-mechanical properties of mineral and ice inclusions; the stress-strain state of ground; the design temperature;
  • deformations of an ice-rich soil are shown as the sum of compaction and creep strains;
  • at low stresses, the rate of creep of an ice-rich soil is determined predominantly by the creep of ice layers, while at high stresses it is a function of the creep strains of ice and soil components;
  • at low stresses, the steady-state creep of an ice-rich soil arises at rise of the steady-state creep of mineral layers;
  • the condition of strains continuity and assumption of linear additivity of pressure in both ice and mineral inclusions are considered;
  • in short-term tests, the long-term strength of an ice-rich soil is determined mainly by the strength of an ice-poor soil, while in long-term tests (low stresses) it depends upon the strength of components;
  • experimental determination of the mechanical properties of an ice-rich soil can be fulfilled according to the uniaxial or triaxial compression test of ice and non-ice-rich soil, and also according to the model test;
  • analysis of bearing capacity of foundations and appropriate deformations of ice-rich soils can be fulfilled by as the well-known methods using the proposed formulas and tables for determination of mechanical characteristics, as new methods which embrace non-linear behavior of ground and pile foundations (the sections 8,10 and 11 of the book).

The determination of the mechanical properties of ice-rich soils according to the components' properties is carried out by means of analysis using the approaches applied in the theory of composite materials. The theoretical investigations are fulfilled taking into account the numerous experimental data published in the literature and obtained in laboratorial tests of soil samples, punches and model piles.

The computation of long-term strength and steady-state creep rate can be made by the regression analysis, the appropriate design values of the mechanical characteristics being determined when necessary. The estimation of these values carries out taking into account their deviations from the average experimental values, with the help of the reliability coefficient which is determined by the specially developed numerical procedure through the analysis of confidence zones for the regression line (the section 14 of the book).

A particular attention is paid to the manner of alteration of the steady-state creep rate and long-term strength of the components in the range of low stresses which are close to the long-term strength. There is studied the fact (revealed by the author) of altering the intensity of the decrease in the strength of ice and clay soils as the time-before-destruction increases, as well as the alterations in the intensity of the decrease in the steady creep rate in the range of low stresses (a bend of the appropriate regression lines).

The results of the computations of the creep-strength, point of fluidity, linear creep limit, steady creep rate, long-term strength and other magnitudes of the ice-rich soils fulfilled by the formulas obtained on the basis of the composite approach are compared with the results of the multifactor tests. The uniaxial compression and model tests of the ice, non-ice-rich and ice-rich soils have been conducted in addition necessarily. The resultant conclusions are confirmed by the stamp and prototype pile tests.

Based on the theoretical and experimental studies, the work provides the following:

  • formulas for computation of the mechanical characteristics of ice-rich soils as per the similar characteristics of the components or ice-rich soils with a different ice content;
  • proposals for laboratory and field tests;
  • new methods of foundation analysis at both linear and non-linear statements.

Use of the suggested technique in practice of geocryological research and foundations designing allows to reduce considerably, or exclude completely, carrying out tests of frozen soils with various iciness.

Comments are represented through the author e-mail on the website:

https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version


Test-Free Determination of Mechanical Properties of Saline Frozen Soils

The method is described in the book of D.Sc. A. Gerasimov “Foundations in Permafrost” (sections 1.2, 4, 6.2, 7.2.1, 8, 10, 14, 15):
https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version

Preview

  1. Analytic method for test-free determination of mechanical characteristics of saline frozen soils as composite materials.
  2. An improved way of computing the design values of mechanical characteristics of soils by the method of the smallest squares.
  3. A design methods for calculation bearing capacity and settlement of pile and columnar foundations on saline frozen ground deforming in the unsteady creep stage.

The Objective of the Research


The research objective is to develop theoretically and substantiate experimentally the analytic methods for determination of the mechanical properties (long-term strength, point of fluidity, viscosity coefficient, unsteady creep parameters and design resistances) of saline frozen soils with various degree of salinity and different ionic composition of salts by the properties of a similar non-saline soil or a saline soil with a different salinity, with a correction for the physical properties of the soil investigated.

Approaches

The working hypotheses approved experimentally:

  • the mechanical properties of frozen soils are to a great extent conditioned by the unfrozen water amount depending upon many factors, of which the main ones are temperature, salinity, dispersion and peat content of soils (and as they increase the unfrozen water amount also increases), as well as ionic composition of salts in pore water;
  • the well-known analytic models applied in frozen soil mechanics have been used to determine strength and creep of the saline soils;
  • saline frozen soils are characterized by considerable deformation at the primary (unsteady) creep stage which, as a rule, should be taken into account when designing;
  • to describe quantitatively, the unfrozen water and ice amount in soil in a wide temperature range, as well as the dependence of the mechanical properties upon various factors, have been taken into consideration, allowing to obtain the universal formulas;
  • when determining the design temperature of saline permafrost, the significant influence of temperature upon thermal and mechanical properties of frozen saline soil should be taken into account;
  • rheological properties of saline frozen soils at the same homologous temperature are often not depended practically on their salinity and ionic composition of salts.


The investigations of the dependence of the saline soils' mechanical properties upon the determining factors are conducted by analyzing the numerous experimental data published in the literature, as well as those obtained in the underground arctic laboratory। The quantitative evaluation of the dependence of these properties upon temperature is fulfilled by the well-known formulas.

The computation of the unfrozen water amount, long-term strength, the point of fluidity, the viscosity coefficient, unsteady creep parameters and design resistances of soils is made by the regression method, the appropriate design values of the mechanical parameters being determined when necessary.

The rigorous estimation of these values can be made taking into account their deviations from the average test values, with the help of the reliability coefficient which is determined by the specially developed numerical procedure through the analysis of confidence zones for the regression line.

The ascertained analytical relationships allow to determine the rheological properties by the similar properties of a non-saline soil or a saline soil with a different salinity and by the simplest physical properties of the soil investigated, commonly without analyzing its unfrozen water amount in the temperature range and determining the ionic composition of salts.

Determination of the design temperature of saline permafrost soils used to find the design values of the mechanical characteristics which are applied in calculations of bearing capacity and settlement foundations is fulfilled based on the analysis of thermal regime of permafrost.

Effective thermal characteristics of soils can be used in the calculations taking into account the soil's unfrozen water amount in the negative temperature range.

The thermal regime is analyzed by the numerical methods in a number of cases. Then the results of the numerical calculations are compared with the results of the computations of design values of temperature by the approximated analytic solutions including those recommended by the standards. The simplified methods to determine the design maximum (for columnar foundations) and equivalent (for pile foundations) temperature of saline soils are considered.

Based on the theoretical and experimental studies, the given information can provide the following:

  • formulas for computation of the mechanical characteristics of saline soils by the similar characteristics of a non-saline soil or a saline soil with a different salinity;
  • the list of the simplest physical properties of saline soils to be determined when exploring;
  • the recommendations on determination of the design values of physical and mechanical characteristics of saline soils with test data statistical processing by the improved method of the smallest squares;
  • a design method for determination of the design temperature of saline soils in order to analyze bearing capacity and settlement of columnar and pile foundations;
  • use of the progressive estimation methods for bearing capacity and settlement analysis when the unsteady creep of ground - at linear and nonlinear dependence its strains on stresses.

Comments are represented through the author e-mail on the website:

https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version


The Express-Method for Determination of Mechanical Properties of Frozen Soils in Laboratory and Field Tests

The method is described in the book of D.Sc. A. Gerasimov “Foundations in Permafrost” (sections 4, 5.2.1, 7.3, 8.5.3, 10.1, 10.2, 14):
https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version

The objective of the method is to develop theoretically and substantiate experimentally the Express-Method for determination of the long-term strength (bearing capacity) and unsteady creep (settlement) parameters of frozen soils in laboratory and field tests.

Profit

The proposed Express-Method is:
  • time saving, as less time is required for each load increment;
  • money saving, as the prototype piles can be substituted by the reference ones, without affecting the reliability of the data obtained;
  • applicable in any season, time of the year and permafrost temperature being considered when interpreting the results obtained.

The Method is distinguished for:

  • its versatility, as it may prove useful for testing punches, pile models, prototype piles and soil samples; it can be applied for the cases of separate as well as joint response of the pile lateral surface and pile end, for both reinforced concrete and metal or wooden piles;
  • comprehensiveness of the data obtained (test results help predict not only the frozen soils' mechanical characteristics, but the foundation bearing capacity and its settlement within the design maintenance life of the structure);
  • high reliability of the predicted values.

Approaches

The working hypotheses approved experimentally:

  • character of creep of the frozen soils is different for the ranges of stresses of the higher and lower long-term strength;
  • soil strains at variable stresses occurs in accordance with the theory of strengthening;
  • the well-known analytic models applied in soil mechanics have been used to determine the long-term strength and creep strains of the frozen soils at constant stresses.

The new Express-Method is based on the soil deformation theoretical model being worked out, which is described by the theory of strengthening; the parameters of such deformation and bearing capacity are determined basing as on the usual linear regression analysis as on the plural regression analysis of the deformation equation.

The advantages and disadvantages of the well-known methods of processing the laboratory and field test data are analyzed, and these methods are compared with each other and with the proposed means of processing the data of the experiments carried out at different modes of loading.

Based on the theoretical investigations and analysis of many field tests of prototype and model piles (with the pile's lateral surface and end working both separately or jointly), the influence of stress-strain state of soils, cross-sectional size, material and roughness of the lateral surfaces of piles upon their bearing capacity and settlement is studied। According to the data of these investigations, the conditions of modeling are formulated and the possibilities are determined to carry out model tests of the reference piles of smaller sizes as well as the laboratory express-technique tests instead of the field tests of the piles of design sizes.

The possibility of using the proposed Express-Method for the field tests of piles and punches in unfrozen clay soils can be analyzed by the same way, followed by the appropriate experimental data.

Based on the theoretical and experimental studies, the method provides the following:

  • qualitative and quantitative assessments of the advantages and disadvantages of the existing methods of frozen soil testing;
  • a universal Express-Method for determination of the mechanical properties of frozen soils in laboratory and field tests of various types (samples of uniaxial and triaxial compression, laboratory models of the foundations, punches, reference and prototype piles with the lateral surface and end working separately or jointly) and at different modes of loading (constant or stepped loads of any duration, including those of different duration);
  • a universal computer program for the quantitative assessment of the mechanical properties of frozen soils with the given confidence probability on the basis of the proposed method;
  • criteria of modeling and recommendations on the technique of express-tests.

Comments are represented through the author e-mail on the website:
https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version

Effective Means to Enhance Bearing Capacity and Reduce Settlement of Permafrost Foundations

The methods are described in the book of D.Sc. A. Gerasimov “Foundations in Permafrost” (sections 8 - 17) and in the other publications:
https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version

An enhancement of design bearing capacity of the columnar and pile foundations on permafrost can be achieved usually by the following means:

  • considering the variability of permafrost temperatures, rheological properties and the external loads and actions;
  • using means of optimizing the piles cross-section shape;
  • applying progressive technological decision of foundations arrangement including use the composition of the mortar poured down pile boreholes;
  • by change in the metal and ferroconcrete piles lateral surfaces condition, and by special sand bed under foundations;
  • by application of seasonally operating cooling devices.

Settlement reduction of foundations on permafrost ground is achieved by the specified above means. Besides, it is possible to take into consideration at designing the following rated techniques:

  • using rigorous nonlinear methods of settlement analysis;
  • taking into strict account for columnar foundations a greater effect of their undercutting in ground; the analysis of settlement caused by the creep of frozen soils is conducted in this case by considering the factors reflecting the stress-strain state below the foundations and their actual footing depth.

The bearing capacity enhancement effect may rise to 300% at the load and soil temperature variability considered, and to 200% - due to structural and technological know-how. The base settlement reduction effect may constitute approximately from 50 to 200% depending on the foundation footing depth.

Comments are represented through the author e-mail on the website: https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version


Determination of Design Loads upon Foundations in Cold Regions

The methods are described in the book of D.Sc. A. Gerasimov “Foundations in Permafrost (sections 5, 7, 8, 10 - 17):
https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version

The objective of the present research is to develop the rheological principles of deterministic and probabilistic methods for analysis of permafrost foundations and in such a manner to increase the loads allowable on these foundations.

Profit:

  1. An original technique to determine reliability of foundations.
  2. An original technique to determine the reliability coefficients for loads and soils temperature, as well as design loads upon foundations of the buildings being erected on permafrost.
  3. The possibility to apply the results obtained in practice is provided because all the solutions are presented in the form acceptable for designing and are followed by the numerical values of the coefficients applied and calculation examples.
  4. A decrease in the design values of temporary loads upon foundations by 10-100%.
  5. An increase in bearing capacity and decrease in settlements of frozen soils up to 300% (in comparison with other probabilistic models) due to the probabilistic variability of loads and soils temperature while constructing and maintaining a structure.
Approaches

The working hypotheses approved experimentally and substantiated theoretically:

  • values of the design loads upon structural elements are conditioned by necessity to ensure reliability of foundations and structures;
  • the loads on foundations and temperature of permafrost soils are random processes, but at simplified analysis they can rated as random or deterministic magnitudes;
  • the frozen soil deformation and strength are random functions of time; by the end of the design service life, their long-term random values can differ significantly from the «instantaneous» ones: the long-term strength can differ several times and in some cases - even tens of times, and deformations can differ tens, hundreds of times and even greater;
  • the random character of variation of load, temperature and frozen soils properties while calculating their long-term bearing capacity and both steady and unsteady creep strains can be considered by means of linear summation of damage, theory of strengthening and summation of plastic and viscous creep deformations; at simplified analysis an evaluation of bearing capacity can curried out by simplified means basing on the long-term values of ground resistance;
  • the determination of design loads acting upon foundations (snow, wind, crane, people, equipment, etc।) and the probabilistic analysis of the frozen foundations should be fulfilled by the offered method based on the cumulative probability model which is single for both groups of the limiting states, taking into account the rheological properties of frozen soils and ice and the random character of variation of external loads and actions in time; considering the external loads and actions as random processes and taking into account the dependence of strains and strength of frozen soils and ice upon time, one can significantly increase correctness of determination of the design values of bearing capacity and settlement of foundations.

The results of the experimental studies on strength and creep of frozen soils and ice at variable loads, published in the literature and specially fulfilled in order to substantiate the accepted design models, are thoroughly analyzed. The statistic variability of long-term strength and creep parameters of frozen soils and ice is studied relying on the statistic-correlation analysis of the test results.

Based on the literature data and theoretical models, the temperature variability of permafrost during a year and in the course of a building maintenance is analyzed in probabilistic terms, and the probabilistic parameters of the mechanical properties of soils and their temperature are found out for application in the probabilistic analysis.

According to the literature data and climate reference books, the probabilistic characteristics of the external loads acting upon foundations are analyzed, particularly the short-term ones having an increased variability (climatic loads, people, equipment, etc.). Also, the periodic variability of these characteristics is studied and the dependence upon time in the course of maintenance of a building is determined.

The reliability of foundations is investigated in terms of the theory of probability, including the theory of random processes. The probability of foundations safe working is determined through analysis by two groups of the limiting states, including necessary relationships between loads and mechanical properties of soils. A probabilistic cumulative model is formed, as well as a semiprobabilistic cumulative model allowing to calculate a foundation, using particular reliability coefficients (for a load, temperature, soil, etc.).

The estimation of the design load values is made by the semiprobabilistic method, in accordance with which the probabilistic variability of a single or several factors is considered, provided that the others are predetermined. The appearing errors are taken into account. The formulas to calculate bearing capacity and settlement of frozen soils and ice, taking into consideration the probabilistic variability of loads, are received along with the appropriate calculation examples. The problem of combining the loads is investigated and necessary recommendations are given.

The environmental loads (snow and wind), just like the bearing capacity of soils and foundations upon vertical and horizontal loads, vary periodically. The coordination of their design values during a year is considered and the possibility for refinement of the design loads upon foundations depending on the accepted calculating scheme is determined (analysis of the bearing capacity of frozen soils, frost heave, piles for horizontal wind load). The correctness of using the principle of coordination is analyzed on the basis of the proposed cumulative model and some appropriate calculation examples are given.

The main results of the present work are as follows:

  • a method for determination of safety of the permafrost, while calculating its bearing capacity and settlement taking into account deformation and failure of frozen soils in time, statistic indeterminacy of their mechanical properties and alteration of load and temperature in the form of random processes and random magnitudes; the above method results in the methods for determination of particular reliability coefficients and design parameters which can be used when calculating foundations;
  • some practical methods are offered to analyze foundations on the permafrost, taking into account the random variability of the climatic and other loads, along with the simplified methods for consideration of the statistic nature of loads of different types while calculating bearing capacity and settlement of frozen soils and ice;
  • some lowered design values of short-time loads transferred onto foundations and structures are recommended.

The conducted investigations will allow not only to increase trustworthiness of determination of the soils' reological properties and formulate the reological principles for the probabilistic analysis of foundations, but also to refine the design values of settlement and bearing capacity of foundations and the external actions by determining the former with consideration for the random variability of loads, temperature and properties of soils.

Comments are represented through the author e-mail on the website: https://sites.google.com/site/permafrostfoundations/english-version